| YEAR | PLAYER | |
| 1ST | 1983 | Dave Davis |
| 2ND | 1984 | Bud Chapman |
| 3RD | 1985 | Bud Chapman |
| 4TH | 1986 | Jim Thompson |
| 5TH | 1987 | Dave Davis |
| 6TH | 1988 | Lonnie Watson |
| 7TH | 1989 | Bud Chapman |
| 8TH | 1990 | Jim Thompson |
| 9TH | 1991 | Bud Chapman |
| 10TH | 1992 | Val Melideo |
| 11TH | 1993 | Bob Rankin |
| 12TH | 1994 | Bob Rankin |
| 13TH | 1995 | Ron LeClair |
| 14TH | 1996 | Spencer Gaylord |
| 15TH | 1997 | Jerry Maxfield |
| 16TH | 1998 | Don Lucas |
| 17TH | 1999 | Jerry Maxfield |
| 18TH | 2000 | Curt Madson |
| 19TH | 2001 | Don Lucas |
| 20TH | 2002 | Spencer Gaylord |
| 21ST | 2003 | Brian Jeffery |
| 22ND | 2004 | Don Lucas |
| 23RD | 2005 | Doug Root |
| 24TH | 2006 | Doug Root |
| 25TH | 2007 | Keith Keister |
| 26TH | 2008 | Doug Root |
| 27TH | 2009 | Jim Holbrook |
| 28TH | 2010 | Stuart Sierra |
| 29TH | 2011 | Stuart Sierra |
| 30TH | 2012 | Jim Holbrook |
| 31TH | 2013 | Tom Hyland |
| 32TH | 2014 | Tom Hyland |
| 33RD | 2015 | Dennis Monahan |
| 34TH | 2016 | Dennis Monahan |
| 35TH | 2017 | Jimmy Jones Sr. |
| 36TH | 2018 | Jimmy Jones Sr. |
| 37TH | 2019 | Robert Bechtol |
| 38TH | 2020 | Don Whittemore |
| 39TH | 2021 | Mike Barkley |
| 40TH | 2022 | Mike Barkley |