| YEAR | PLAYER | |
| 1ST | 2006 | Dalton Melnyk |
| 2ND | 2007 | Alan Bratton |
| 3RD | 2008 | Jonathan Mathias |
| 4TH | 2009 | Mike Barbosa |
| 5TH | 2010 | Dennis Monahan |
| 6TH | 2011 | Billy Williamson |
| 7TH | 2012 | Billy Williamson |
| 8TH | 2013 | Joe Alfieri |
| 9TH | 2014 | Joe Alfieri |
| 10TH | 2015 | Miles McConnell |
| 11TH | 2016 | Joe Alfieri |
| 12TH | 2017 | Darin Goldstein |
| 13TH | 2018 | Devin Hernandez |
| 14TH | 2019 | Joe Lyons |
| 15TH | 2020 | Troy Vannucci |
| 16TH | 2021 | Toby Ragland |
| 17TH | 2022 | David Lang |