| YEAR | PLAYER | YEAR | PLAYER | |||
| 1ST | 1927 | A.T. Cooper | 50TH | 1976 | Buddy Alexander | |
| 2ND | 1928 | Johnny Revolta | 51TH | 1977 | Buddy Alexander | |
| 3RD | 1929 | Bob Lassing | 52ND | 1978 | Buddy Alexander | |
| 4TH | 1930 | Bob Lassing | 53RD | 1979 | Joe Hodge | |
| 5TH | 1931 | Bob Hamilton | 54TH | 1980 | Gary Halberg | |
| 6TH | 1932 | Bob Hamilton | 55TH | 1981 | Bob Michael | |
| 7TH | 1933 | Bob Hamilton | 56TH | 1982 | Robert Stanger | |
| 8TH | 1934 | Bayard Mitchell | 57TH | 1983 | Ken Mattiace | |
| 9TH | 1935 | Bob Hamilton | 58TH | 1984 | Bobby Dick | |
| 10TH | 1936 | Bob Hamilton | 59TH | 1985 | Jim Shely | |
| 11TH | 1937 | Sam Messner | 60TH | 1986 | Lenny Mattiace | |
| 12TH | 1938 | Harold Miller | 61ST | 1987 | Buddy Alexander | |
| 13TH | 1939 | Jim Caputo | 62ND | 1988 | Tom Carr | |
| 14TH | 1940 | Jim Caputo | 63RD | 1989 | Lee Porter | |
| 15TH | 1941 | Jim Caputo | 64TH | 1990 | Todd Mudge | |
| 16TH | 1942 | Jim Caputo | 65TH | 1991 | Buddy Alexander | |
| 17TH | 1943 | Jim Caputo | 66TH | 1992 | Michael Cloer | |
| 18TH | 1944 | Jim Caputo | 67TH | 1993 | John Corzilius | |
| 19TH | 1945 | Frank Ligget | 68TH | 1994 | Daniel Stone | |
| 20TH | 1946 | Woody Wever | 69TH | 1995 | Darron Stiles | |
| 21ST | 1947 | Woody Wever | 70TH | 1996 | Ryuji Imada | |
| 22ND | 1948 | Ed Updegraff | 71ST | 1997 | John Corzilius | |
| 23RD | 1949 | Ward Rogers | 72ND | 1998 | Kevin Mock | |
| 24TH | 1950 | Hugh Hays | 73RD | 1999 | Steve Scott | |
| 25TH | 1951 | Woody Wever | 74TH | 2000 | Jeff Klauk | |
| 26TH | 1952 | Jim Erwin | 75TH | 2001 | Akio Sadakata | |
| 27TH | 1953 | Hobart Manley | 76TH | 2002 | John Corzilius | |
| 28TH | 1954 | Hobart Manley | 77TH | 2003 | J. B. Holmes | |
| 29TH | 1955 | Sam Friedman | 78TH | 2004 | Brandt Snedeker | |
| 30TH | 1956 | Bob Goalby | 79TH | 2005 | Jeff Overton | |
| 31ST | 1957 | Wayne Dailey | 80TH | 2006 | Luke List | |
| 32ND | 1958 | Peter Arend | 81ST | 2007 | Major Manning | |
| 33RD | 1959 | Peter Arend | 82ND | 2008 | Bryce Ledford | |
| 34TH | 1960 | Peter Arend | 83RD | 2009 | Peter Uihlein | |
| 35TH | 1961 | Glenn Peoples | 84TH | 2010 | Tommy Mou | |
| 36TH | 1962 | Bun Cotton | 85TH | 2011 | Brandon Hagy | |
| 37TH | 1963 | Richard Leckey | 86TH | 2012 | Garland Green | |
| 38TH | 1964 | Jack Veghte | 87TH | 2013 | Toni Hakula | |
| 39TH | 1965 | Denny Lyons | 88TH | 2014 | Sam Horsfield | |
| 40TH | 1966 | Jack Veghte | 89TH | 2015 | Sam Horsfield | |
| 41ST | 1967 | Marion Heck | 90TH | 2016 | Jimmy Jones | |
| 42ND | 1968 | Denny Lyons | 91ST | 2017 | Hayden Buckley | |
| 43RD | 1969 | Bob Rankin | 92ND | 2018 | Hayden Buckley | |
| 44TH | 1970 | Eddie Pearce | 93RD | 2019 | Kyler Tate | |
| 45TH | 1971 | Phil Leckey | 94TH | 2020 | Nick Gabrelcik | |
| 46TH | 1972 | Buddy Alexander | 95TH | 2021 | Remi Chartier | |
| 47TH | 1973 | Bill Harvey | 96TH | 2022 | Remi Chartier | |
| 48TH | 1974 | Gary Koch | ||||
| 49TH | 1975 | Bill Harvey |